As I mentioned yesterday, there are things I love and things I don’t in children’s books. Here are a few of these:
Don’t like:
- Counting books (usually too didactic & repetitive)
- Books that try to teach (colours, numbers, pretty much anything), particularly the authorless “educational” ones like Baby Einstein … shudder
- Sarcasm and adult humour (so jading for children!)
- Focusing on “are you good?”, punishments and/or “consequences” (Berenstein Bears books are bad for this) as these feel way too manipulative
- Male-centric or non-gender equal texts (note: this doesn’t mean that every book needs a female carpenter or a working mother, but please, try to transcend gender stereotypes a bit. And write about girls: they have adventures too!)
- When things have to fall apart too far (e.g., the first half of the book is a big fight) before they get better, and the getting better part isn’t very well-developed or long
- Leveled reading books, with their corresponding lack of any literary value (some exceptions, notably the Elephant & Piggie series by Mo Willems)
- A good portion of computer-generated illustrations and some mixed media (nothing wrong with these, but I just don’t enjoy the juxtaposition, for example, of fabric samples with photos with computer art. Mo Willems & the Knuffle Bunny books are again an exception)
What I love:
- Real art for the illustrations, in widely varying styles
- Humour
- Stories with a twist, imaginative adventures, and/or a focus on relationships, friendship & family
- Stories about girls and women
- Evocations of home and family
In summary: I love real stories, put together with care and skill, that see children as imaginative and discerning readers. I shy away from books that seem designed to manipulate children’s behaviour or act as disguised rote learning activities, put together on the quick and cheap.
Long live children’s literature!
No responses yet